Tenant Modifications: How to Protect Your Property from Damage

As rental laws evolve across Australia, many renters are now allowed to make minor modifications to rental properties, sometimes without needing the residential rental provider’s approval. These changes can range from installing child safety devices and picture hooks to more significant modifications like painting or adding security cameras. But this shift in tenancy legislation leaves residential rental providers with important questions: When does a “minor modification” become property damage? Who is responsible for fixing it? And, most importantly, will your landlord insurance cover the cost of these changes?


Where the Lines Between Modifications and Damage Get Blurry

Legislation on renter modifications varies by state, but in most cases, renters have more freedom than ever before to make small changes to rental properties. While this might make renters feel more at home, it creates a grey area for residential rental providers. When does a minor modification cross the line and become damage? A picture hook is one thing, but what if a renter decides to repaint an entire room without permission?

In some cases, renters no longer need your approval for minor modifications. But what happens if they make bigger changes or leave modifications in place when they vacate? If a renter alters the property without permission or fails to return it to its original state, it can be considered property damage. For example, if a renter paints the walls black and leaves it that way, this could be seen as damage, depending on your jurisdiction and whether your insurance provides protection.


Is Property Damage Covered by Landlord Insurance?

One of the most important questions for residential rental providers is whether damage caused by renter modifications is covered by landlord insurance. Insurance policies often offer coverage for accidental, malicious, or deliberate property damage caused by renters. However, if the modification was allowed under rental law or done with your approval, it might not be classified as “damage.”

For example, if a renter installs picture hooks or temporary window treatments without your permission and leaves them behind, this may be considered damage. But if these modifications comply with local tenancy legislation, they may not qualify as damage under your insurance policy. Knowing your state’s rental laws and the specifics of your insurance policy is crucial to protecting your investment.


How to Protect Your Investment Property

As a residential rental provider, it’s essential to protect your investment property from unnecessary wear and tear while ensuring compliance with changing tenancy laws. Here’s how you can safeguard your property:

  1. Understand Tenancy Laws and Rights: Each state and territory has different rules regarding what constitutes a “minor modification.” Knowing when you can reasonably refuse a renter’s request and when you must comply is key to staying compliant.
  2. Communicate with Renters: Open communication with your renters can prevent misunderstandings. Discuss any modification requests upfront, and clarify whether the renter will need to return the property to its original condition when they vacate.
  3. Request an Additional Bond: In some cases, residential rental providers can ask renters for an extra bond to cover the cost of reinstating the property to its original state after modifications. This provides financial security if modifications aren’t reversed.
  4. Review Your Landlord Insurance: Not all landlord insurance policies are the same. Review your policy to understand what types of damage are covered and whether modifications made by renters are included. It’s essential to know the limits of your policy and ensure it offers sufficient protection for property damage caused by unauthorised changes.

What Happens When Modifications Become Property Damage?

When renters make unauthorised modifications, or modifications are poorly executed and lead to damage, residential rental providers could face costly repairs. Even seemingly minor changes, like installing wall anchors, can cause damage that needs to be fixed. In more extreme cases, such as an unapproved paint job or large modifications that affect the structure of the property, this could result in significant damage.

If a renter fails to restore the property to its original condition, this could be considered property damage. In such situations, landlord insurance may cover the repair costs, but only if the modification was unauthorised and the renter didn’t fulfil their obligation to reinstate the property. If the modification was made with your approval or allowed under tenancy legislation, insurance coverage may not apply.


Final Thoughts: Striking the Balance Between Flexibility and Protection

With more renters allowed to make modifications to properties without approval, it’s essential for residential rental providers to stay informed about their rights and responsibilities. Balancing renter satisfaction with protecting your investment property can be challenging, but with open communication, a clear understanding of tenancy laws, and the right insurance coverage, you can safeguard your property from unnecessary damage.

By keeping up with rental laws, setting clear expectations with your renters, and ensuring your landlord insurance provides adequate protection, you can minimise risk and avoid disputes. If you find yourself facing damage from renter modifications, don’t hesitate to reach out to your insurance provider.

As a residential rental provider, it’s crucial to know when a modification enhances the property and when it becomes property damage. Stay informed, protect your property, and make sure you’re covered – no matter what modifications your renters make.

For more information on this topic, click here

Or if you’d like to speak with one of our team of experts click here


*The information provided in this blog post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or insurance advice. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the content, we recommend consulting with qualified professionals, such as legal advisors, financial consultants, or insurance brokers, to discuss your specific situation and obtain advice tailored to your circumstances. The laws and regulations regarding rental properties and modifications can vary by location, and it is important to seek expert guidance before making any decisions. The content provided here does not create a client relationship and should not be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice.*